I asked a founder last week about the last deal his team lost.
He paused.
Then he said they went with a competitor, and he wasn’t sure why. Probably price. We got into the deal late. Also buyer may have had a prior relationship.
Multiple reasons often confirms the truth. “We don’t really know.”
That’s the common case. I’ve had this conversation with 300+ founders, and most can’t name the real reason behind their last loss. They give me a label instead. A label lives in Salesforce and often tells us very little.
Once you have sellers, the problem gets worse. You weren’t on the calls. You hear the rep’s version, and the rep’s version is usually the buyer’s version. Many of us know the saying “buyers are liars.”
If you’re still the one selling, you have the opposite problem. You were on every call. You know what the buyer said, and it’s hard to see past it, especially when the deal was yours.
Founders used to lose because a competitor could do something they couldn’t. That’s rare now. Today the losses come from somewhere else, and you can’t fix them until you can see them.
So here’s the exercise.
Pull your last three losses. If you have sellers, have each of them do the same. For every loss, write a single sentence (2 max) about why you actually lost. Write what you believe happened, not what the buyer said.
Then sort them, with your team if you have one.
First, pull out the deals that were never a fit. Wrong company, wrong buyer, and nothing you could have learned would have changed that. Losing those was fine. The fix is narrowing who you go after, and that’s on you as the founder.
What’s left are the deals you should have won. When I dig into these with founders, the same four reasons come up again and again. Each one has a question underneath it.
Budget. Could they never afford it, or did they decide not to spend? If they could never afford it, move it back to the wrong fit pile. If they chose not to spend, you’re usually looking at a lack of urgency. Buyers with a real reason to act tend to find the money.
We got in too late. By the time you showed up, the buyer had a favorite. The obvious question is why they picked someone else. The better question is when they started looking, and where you were. Hold onto that one.
They built it themselves. Did they see what building it would really cost them? If nobody put a number on that, you let them compare your price to a free option that wasn’t free.
No urgency. The pain was found. The buyer agreed it was real. Did anyone ask what changed that makes solving it matter now? Deals like this rarely end with a no. They go quiet, and the CRM says “timing.”
Most founders can’t tell me which of these is costing them deals. Run this exercise and you’ll find out.
I learned this the hard way at Outreach. We lost a deal that was squarely in our ICP, exactly the kind of account where we won most often. We had every right to win it.
The seller told me we lost because the buyer had a prior relationship with the competitor and we got in late.
So I spoke with the buyer. They didn’t mention a relationship. They didn’t mention timing. They said the other team gave them more confidence that they understood the problem and could solve it.
That one stung. We didn’t lose on timing. We got out-executed.
Sellers will almost never tell you they got out-executed. Even the four reasons above can be cover stories. That’s why the buyer has to be part of this.
Your sentences are still a guess. The buyer knows the real answer.
After that, I started reaching out directly to every closed-lost deal where we’d put in real effort. Most loss reviews ask one question: why did the buyer choose someone else?
Ask when they started looking, too. What set it off? Whatever it was, that’s the signal you missed.
One answer is an anecdote. Three answers start to show you what tends to happen right before someone needs what you sell. That’s the list your outbound should be built around, and it came from deals you already lost.
The process I used changed a lot over time as I learned what got people to answer honestly. I’m happy to share what worked and how it evolved. If you’re interested, just reply.

